Pathogen-pesticide-host interaction: Apoptosis modulation by Nosema ceranae increases honeybee susceptibility to the insecticide cyantraniliprole
Pathogen-pesticide-host interaction: Apoptosis modulation by Nosema ceranae increases honeybee susceptibility to the insecticide cyantraniliprole
Introduction
Bees play a crucial role in providing pollination services to majority of flowering plants and are essential for the conservation of both ecosystems and biodiversity [17], [26]. Their importance also extends to agricultural systems, as Apis mellifera Linnaeus (Hymenoptera: Apidae) is the most widely used species for pollinating commercial crops, contributing to the production of up to one-third of the human diet that depends on pollination [39]. Additionally, this species produces valuable products such as honey, wax, propolis, royal jelly, and apitoxins [74], underscoring its ecological, economic, and social significance.
However, the ongoing decline in pollinator populations and diversity is a growing concern, affecting both managed and wild bee species [63], including honey bees, Apis mellifera [66]. This decline is attributed to multiple factors, such as interspecific competition, poor nutrition, habitat loss and fragmentation, climate change, the spread of pathogens, and the use of pesticides in agricultural practices [29], [45], [7].
Among pesticides, insecticides—when applied at lethal doses—negatively impact bee colonies by reducing overall field populations ([78]; Seitz et al., 2022). Sublethal effects also have significant risks, changing the bee morphology, physiology, and behavior. These include olfactory disruptions, impaired learning and memory, paralysis, reduced survival, and disorientation, which compromise pollination services and colony maintenance (Basu and [11]). Additional sublethal effects include increased oxidative stress [15] and susceptibility to pathogens due to reduced immunocompetence [5], [73]. Both acute and chronic sublethal exposures have gained increasing attention (vanEngelsdorp and Meixner, 2010; [3]), especially since studies using non-field-realistic concentrations raise concerns about the applicability of their findings [4]. As a result, research using field-realistic concentrations under chronic exposure scenarios has become increasingly urgent.
Among pesticides, anthranilic diamides such as cyantraniliprole, act on ryanodine receptors in calcium channels [43]. This compound has systemic activity and is effective in controlling pests in soybean and coffee crops, both of which rely on honeybee pollination. Although calcium channels are primarily known for their role in muscle contraction, calcium homeostasis is involved in numerous essential cellular functions [50], [54]. Therefore, despite the specific mode of action of anthranilic diamides, their effects may be amplified due to the widespread involvement of calcium signaling in various cell types—unlike other insecticides, such as neonicotinoids, which target more restricted cell pathways [49], [58].
Damage to non-target organs such as the midgut is a growing concern, as this organ plays a key role not only in digestion and nutrient absorption [6], but also in detoxification processes in bees [28], [69]. As the primary organ that comes into contact with orally ingested pesticides, the midgut is particularly vulnerable to toxic effects, since these compounds must cross the intestinal barrier to reach their target sites (reviewed by [14]). Pesticides can penetrate the midgut epithelium either through the paracellular route, between cells, or via the transcellular route, through the cells themselves [14].
Cytotoxic effects observed in the midgut include the presence of cells with pyknotic nuclei—an indicator of cell death—and increased cytoplasm vacuolization, both considered key markers of cellular toxicity [50], [59]. Ultrastructural alterations caused by pesticides have also been reported, such as disruptions in the basal labyrinth [67], degeneration of the endoplasmic reticulum, and general organelle deterioration ([65]; Gomez-Virgilio et al., 2022). Notably, some histopathological responses appear to occur predominantly or more severely in specific midgut regions—for example, an increased number of cytoplasm protrusions and the release of cell fragments in the posterior midgut [3]. These damages may trigger programmed cell death pathways, including apoptosis and autophagy [46].
Apoptosis in the insect midgut has several functions both in development [35] and in tissue maintenance ([19]; Martin-Hernandezet et al., 2017). Thus, apoptosis is essential in the elimination and disposal of senescent cells resulting from stress due to their intrinsic metabolic activities in what is considered tissue regeneration [44]. In addition, it plays an important role in the elimination of cells resulting from exogenous stressors, such as pathogens and toxic molecules [20], [35], [46]. Intracellular pathogens infect cells, which may activate the cell death program, obliterating both the compromised cell and the infecting microorganisms before the end of their cycle and multiplication, in order to discard them into the gut lumen [13]. Cell death is relevant not only in defense against pathogens, but in toxicological contexts, eliminating contaminated, intoxicated and nonviable cells, contributing to the return of tissue homeostasis ([55]; Bertherloot et al., 2021).
The reduction in bee immunocompetence caused by pesticide exposure is another major concern [73], especially considering that pathogens are among the key factors contributing to bee population declines. This risk is exacerbated by the combined effects of pesticides and pathogens, which increase bees’ susceptibility to toxic impacts. Among the many pathogens that infect bees, the unicellular microorganism Nosema ceranae has been recognized as a global threat [32], [51]. Nosema ceranae infection can lead to nosemosis, characterized by altered behavior and flight activity, reduced survival, oxidative stress, and cytotoxicity ([18], [23]; Goblirsch et al., 2013).
Transmission of Nosema spp. among bees occurs via trophallaxis, allogrooming, and contact with contaminated food (Marín-García et al., 2020). Inside the midgut lumen, spores germinate and colonize the digestive cells [39], with a preference for the posterior portion of the midgut epithelium [60]. This infection is facilitated by the pathogen’s ability to inhibit apoptosis in the midgut [37], [38], [41], [44], [61], [68]. Indeed, A. mellifera strains that are tolerant to N. ceranae do not exhibit reduced apoptosis in midgut cells [41], [44], indicating the crucial role of apoptosis manipulation by microsporidia in the success of intracellular infection. This is particularly relevant given that apoptosis contributes to tissue detoxification and homeostasis ([55]; Bertherloot et al., 2021). Therefore, the suppression of apoptosis by N. ceranae may weaken bees or even amplify the effects of orally ingested pesticides. While the physiological interplay between pathogens and pesticides remains insufficiently understood, investigating whether N. ceranae-induced apoptosis suppression contributes to increased pesticide susceptibility is an important step toward clarifying how this pathogen compromises bee health.
This study investigated whether the pathogen N. ceranae increases the susceptibility of A. mellifera to sublethal exposure to the insecticide cyantraniliprole. The hypothesis tested was that apoptosis suppression in the midgut epithelium by the pathogen is a mediating mechanism responsible for weakening A. mellifera to the insecticide.
Section snippets
Insects
Newly-emerged Africanized A. mellifera worker bees were obtained from brood frames sourced from five colonies at the Central Apiary of the Federal University of Viçosa (Viçosa, Minas Gerais, Brazil). All colonies were healthy, showing no clinical signs of disease, and were located near an Atlantic Forest fragment characterized by high plant diversity and polyfloral resources, in an area free from pesticide exposure. Colonies were maintained in Langstroth hives, each containing approximately 20
Concentration–mortality bioassay
The Probit concentration–mortality model was considered adequate (χ² = 12.20; P > 0.05), allowing the estimation of the lethal concentrations of cyantraniliprole after 24 h (Table 1). No mortality was observed in the control group.
Survival bioassay under chronic exposure
The probability of survival was significantly reduced in bees from the LC₅₀/10+Nosema treatment compared to the control (Fig. 1). Bees exposed to the other treatments did not show significant differences in survival relative to the control (Fig. 1).
Detection of apoptosis in the midgut
Immunofluorescence
Discussion
The results of the mortality bioassay confirm the acute toxicity of cyantraniliprole to Africanized Apis mellifera workers. The estimated LC₅₀ value of 0.039 mg L⁻¹ falls within the concentration range recommended for agricultural pest control, representing a realistic field-level exposure capable of causing lethal effects. Previous acute toxicity studies have also demonstrated the susceptibility of A. mellifera larvae to cyantraniliprole at field-relevant concentrations [40], as well as of
Conclusion
Although cyantraniliprole alone does not affect bees at sublethal concentrations, its combination with the pathogen N. ceranae has a deleterious effect, reducing the survival of Africanized A. mellifera. The ability of N. ceranae to suppress apoptosis may be a key factor in this harmful interaction, weakening the bees' defense responses and increasing their susceptibility to the insecticide.
Overall, this study provides theoretical, empirical, and methodological insights into the interaction
Environmental Implication
This study reveals important environmental implications by showing that the interaction between the pathogen Nosema ceranae and the insecticide cyantraniliprole increases honeybee vulnerability to both stressors. Region-specific modulation of apoptosis in the midgut compromises tissue integrity, particularly in areas with intense pathogen colonization. These findings suggest that prior infections can exacerbate the effects of pesticides, contributing to pollinator population declines. The
CRediT authorship contribution statement
João Victor de Oliveira Motta: Investigation, Methodology, Formal analysis. Lenise Silva Carneiro: Investigation, Methodology, Formal analysis. Diego dos Santos Souza: Validation, Investigation, Methodology. Resende Matheus Tudor Candido Santos: Writing – original draft, Investigation, Conceptualization, Writing – review & editing, Methodology, Formal analysis. Serrao Jose Eduardo: Writing – review & editing, Supervision, Formal analysis, Writing – original draft, Funding acquisition,
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

댓글
댓글 쓰기