The in vitro potential of non-thermal atmospheric pressure plasma against Nosema ceranae infection in honeybees (Apis mellifera)
The in vitro potential of non-thermal atmospheric pressure plasma against Nosema ceranae infection in honeybees (Apis mellifera)
The microsporidia are an obligate intracellular parasite that can infect many vertebrates and invertebrates1,2. Nosema apis and Nosema ceranae are two microsporidian parasites that infect the digestive tract of honeybees (Apis mellifera) and can cause widespread infection3,4,5,6. Additionally, Nosema neumani was recently found as a new pathogen of honeybees in Uganda7. Currently, the genus of Nosema has been reclassified as Vairimorpha8. Although N. apis was first described in A. mellifera in 19969 and N. ceranae was originally found in Apis cerana10N. ceranae has since become the most prevalent microsporidian parasite in adult honeybees worldwide4,11,12,13. Additionally, N. ceranae has been shown to infect larval honeybees in an experimental infection study14. Nosema infection is associated with physiological and behavioral changes in adult honeybees15,16,17,18,19 and the synergistic effects between Nosema and other factors such as parasitic mites, honeybee viruses, pesticides and nutrition limitations can lead to colony losses20.The inhibitor of methionine aminopeptidase-2 (MetAP2), fumagillin has been used to treat Nosema infections21. However, this antibiotic may not be as effective and consistent against N. ceranae infection in the field and residues can lead to antibiotic resistance22. Due to its toxicity to human and other vertebrates, many countries have banned fumagillin for use in honeybee colonies23,24,25. Therefore, alternative approaches to control N. ceranae are needed. Some bacteria and their metabolites have been reported as potential agent to reduce N. ceranae spores26,27,28,29. The miticides used to control Varroa mites, oxalic acid and formic acid have shown some activity against N. ceranae30,31. Natural plant extracts and compounds have reported efficacy on the inactivation of N. ceranae spores in both laboratory and field tests29,31,32,33,34,35,36. Additionally, several substances, e.g., porphyrins, porphyrinoids and zinc phthalocyanine have been investigated for their activity against Nosema37,38,39,40. Among these, the prophyrinoid PP(Asp)2 reduced N. ceranae infectivity in honeybees by 2.6 to 5 times, which was attributed to the destruction of the spore cell walls37. While the spore load in honeybees was reduced by 69–76% on day 18 after treatment with porphyrins in N. ceranae-infected honeybees38. Other substances such as ammonia solution, sodium hypochlorite and Mycoplasma OFF™ have also showed effectiveness in disinfecting equipment contaminated with N. ceranae spores41. Although these compounds demonstrated anti-microsporidian activity against N. ceranae, their effectiveness in controlling Nosema disease in the field has been inconsistent35. Among the various strategies for Nosema control, RNA interference (RNAi) technology has shown an inhibitory effect on N. ceranae and increased the survival rate of honeybees29,42,43,44. The honeybee gut microbiota, Snodgrassella alvi was genetically engineered to induce RNA interference and suppress the expression of genes associated with the thioredoxin and glutathione system of N. ceranae45. Recently, the specific immunoglobulins (IgY) antibodies from egg yolk have been reported as having therapeutic potential for N. ceranae control46. In addition, the use of a DNA damage agent, bleomycin, could reduce N. ceranae infection in honeybees47. However, the practicality and effectiveness of this technique need further investigation. The limitations of these methods used to inactivate Nosema drive ongoing research on new alternative strategies for Nosema control in honeybees. Therefore, the focus of this research was to test non-thermal atmospheric pressure plasma technology for N. ceranae spore inactivation. A recent study has shown that non-thermal plasma effectively inhibited the mycelial growth of Ascosphaera apis, the causative agent of chalkbrood disease in honeybees. This technology reduced the pathogenicity of A. apis in honeybee larvae, resulting in over 50% of inhibition48. Additionally, the efficacy of plasma and plasma activated water (PAW) on microbial inactivation has been reported. Lao et al. (2020) demonstrated that gas plasma and PAW treatments reduced Aspergillus flavus spores and metabolic activity49. PAW also exhibited an antimicrobial activity on Escherichia coli, Listeria innocua and Fusarium graminearum50,51.
The objective of this study was to evaluate the anti-microsporidian activity of gas plasma and PAW on N. ceranae by investigating the spore number and cell wall integrity. To compare the efficiency of plasma and PAW in N. ceranae inactivation, argon and helium were used as working gases, as different gases generate distinct reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (RONS). The physicochemical properties of PAW were also analyzed to explore the correlation between its anti-microsporidian activity and reactive species. The effect of plasma-treated spores on infectivity in adult bees was also examined.
Results
Reactive oxygen and nitrogen species
Figure 1 illustrates the relative intensity of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (RONS) during plasma discharge using argon and helium at the flow rate of 0.5 Liter per minute (Lpm). The emission of O3, OH–, NO, N2 and N2+ are the main contributors in the spectra which corresponds to the wavelengths at 307.9 nm, 302–310 nm, 337–357 nm and 315–405 nm, respectively. The NO species exhibited high intensity in both gases. The high intensity of excited species was obtained more from the helium plasma in comparison with argon plasma.
Physicochemical properties and stability of hydrogen peroxide in PAW
As shown in Table 1, the pH value of PAW generated by argon and helium significantly decreased to 8.407–8.780 from 8.943 and 8.323–8.643 from 8.830, respectively. The electrical conductivity of water was significantly enhanced after increasing time exposure to argon and helium at gas flow rates of 0.25 and 0.5 Lpm. The concentrations of H2O2 in freshly prepared PAW were dramatically increased with increasing treatment time. However, a greater argon flow rate did not affect the H2O2 concentration. The amount of H2O2 reached 200 mg/L after 10 min of activation time. PAW generated using helium exhibited a lower concentration of H2O2 compared to that generated using argon at a flow rate of 0.5 Lpm and an exposure time of 10 min. It ranged between 50 and 150 mg/L. Nitrate and nitrite concentrations were not detected in PAW. In addition, the stability of H2O2 in PAW and 50% (w/v) sucrose solution dissolved in PAW after storage at room temperature for 14 days was also determined. The results showed that H2O2 levels remained relatively stable up to day 6 of storage, after which they declined by 50–80% in argon PAW and by 33.33–80% in helium PAW (Fig. 2). Notably, the lowest reduction in H2O2 concentration was observed in helium PAW treated for 10 min Fig. 2.
Argon and helium plasma in N. ceranae inactivation
The inactivation efficacy of the gas plasma against N. ceranae is shown in Fig. 3a. The number of N. ceranae spores was significantly decreased after argon plasma treatment (Kruskal–Wallis test, p = 0.033). Spore numbers decreased by 86.20–96.55% after direct exposure to argon plasma. The average number of spores were approximately 0.25–1.0 × 105 spores/ml. A similar trend of N. ceranae spore reduction was observed for helium plasma treatment. N. ceranae spores substantially declined by about 67.14–96.05% (Kruskal–Wallis test, p = 0.0242). The highest reduction in spore count was observed when using a helium flow rate of 0.5 Lpm for 5 min of exposure time with 96.05% of reduction.
Inactivation of N. ceranae spores by direct plasma (a) and plasma activated water (b) generated by argon and helium, at the gas flow rate of 0.25 and 0.50 Lpm for 3, 5 and 10 min of exposure time. Different letters indicate significant differences between treatments (Kruskal–Wallis test, Steel–Dwass posthoc; p < 0.05).
Inactivation of N. ceranae spore by PAW
The effect of PAW generated by argon and helium on N. ceranae spores was determined after 1 h of incubation. The results demonstrated that PAW generated by argon had a stronger effect on N. ceranae spores with approximately 50.51–77.14% of reduction (Kruskal–Wallis test, p = 0.0325) (Fig. 3b). The greatest spore reduction was obtained when the higher gas flow rate was applied. Additionally, helium generated PAW reduced the spore number but the reduction was not significant (Kruskal–Wallis test, p > 0.05) (12.38–29.83% of reduction). As H2O2 was the only reactive species detected in PAW, its effects on the inactivation of N. ceranae spores were subsequently evaluated. The results showed that the reduction of spores increased with higher H2O2 concentrations (Fig. 4a). H2O2 at concentrations of 100–300 mg/L significantly reduced N. ceranae spores with 42.64–49.75% of inhibition (Fig. 4b). However, H2O2 at the concentrations up to 100 mg/L did not significantly affect spore reduction.
Viability of N. ceranae spores
The live/dead staining was performed to compare the viability of N. ceranae spores between the control group and those treated with direct plasma or PAW. Quantitative analysis of spore viability following these treatments is shown in Fig. 5a. All plasma-treated groups exhibited significantly reduced spore viability compared to the untreated control. In the direct plasma treatment, spore viability ranged from 58.16 to 65.74%, with the lowest viability observed under argon plasma at 0.5 Lpm for 5 min (Kruskal–Wallis test, p = 0.0029) (Fig. 5a). For PAW treatments, spore viability ranged from 59.30 to 66.11%, with the greatest reduction observed with PAW generated by argon at 0.5 Lpm for 10 min (Fig. 5b). No significant difference in viability was found between helium and argon groups at the same flow rate and exposure time. The results showed that both direct plasma and PAW effectively reduce N. ceranae spore viability, with greater reductions generally achieved with longer treatment durations. As shown in Fig. 5c and d, a high number of non-viable spores (indicated by red fluorescence) were observed following argon plasma treatment (0.5 Lpm for 5 min) and PAW generated under the same conditions for 10 min, respectively.
Assessment of N. ceranae spore viability using the LIVE/DEAD™ assay. Quantitative analysis of viable spores following treatment with direct plasma (a) and PAW (b). Representative fluorescence microscopy images of spores treated with direct plasma (c) and PAW (d) after LIVE/DEAD™ staining (20X magnification). Different letters indicate significant differences between treatments (Kruskal–Wallis test, Steel–Dwass posthoc; p < 0.05).
Leakage of UV-absorbing substances from N. ceranae spores
To determine if gas plasma and PAW disrupted the cell structure and resulted in the loss of cell membrane integrity, the UV-absorbing substances which includes nucleic acids absorbing at 260 nm and proteins absorbing at 280 nm released from N. ceranae spores was measured after plasma treatment. The absorbance values at 260 nm of N. ceranae spore supernatants were significantly increased after argon and helium plasma treatment (Kruskal–Wallis test, p = 0.0004 and p < 0.0001, respectively) as shown in Fig. 6a, c. The substances absorbing at 280 nm also increased following argon plasma treatment, however, no significant difference was observed with helium plasma treatment. PAW generated by argon gas also had an effect on UV-absorbing substances leakage, but the differences were not significant (Fig. 6b). The release of UV-absorbing substances from N. ceranae spore supernatants treated with PAW generated by helium showed no difference except when a gas flow rate of 0.25 Lpm was applied for 3 min (Fig. 3d).
Leakage of UV-absorbing substances from N. ceranae spores treated with direct argon plasma (a), helium plasma (c) and PAW generated by argon (b) and helium (d), measured at wavelengths of 260 nm and 280 nm. Treatments were performed at gas flow rates of 0.25 and 0.50 Lpm for exposure of 3, 5 and 10 min. Different letters (a, b) and (x, y) indicate significant differences between treatments (Kruskal–Wallis test, Steel–Dwass posthoc; p < 0.05).
Disruption of N. ceranae spore morphology
The spore surface was analyzed using SEM. SEM images indicated a difference in the N. ceranae spore surface between untreated and plasma treatment (Fig. 7). The untreated spores were oval-shaped with wrinkles in the spore surface (Fig. 7a, f). The effects of argon and helium on the spore structure were similar. The outer membranes of the spores were fused, and the spores exhibited a rounded shape after gas plasma and PAW treatments (Fig. 7b-m).
Gas plasma and PAW reduce N. ceranae infection in honeybees
The infectivity of N. ceranae spores treated by gas plasma and PAW in adult honeybees using cage experiments is shown in Fig. 8a. The results demonstrated that there were no significant differences in the spore number between the treatment groups on day 7 of experiment (Mixed effects models, p > 0.05). However, the infectivity of the pre-treated spore with gas plasma and PAW was significantly decreased about 71.88–87.42% on day 14 of the experiment (Mixed effects models, p < 0.0001) (Table 2). The results also demonstrated that spore number was reduced after bees were fed ad libitum with sugar dissolved in PAW, a 74.56% reduction (Table 2). In addition, the survival of N. ceranae-infected bees was monitored (Fig. 8b). The survival rate was not significantly different between the treatment groups over 14 days (ANOVA, p > 0.05). However, a higher survival rate was observed in honeybees infected with pre-treated spores with gas plasma and honeybees fed ad libitum with sugar dissolved in PAW (47.5–53.33%) compared to the honeybees infected with untreated spores (44.17%) on day 14. To validate the reproducibility of these findings, an independent replicate of the infectivity experiment was performed (Figure S1). The results were consistent with the initial trial; however, a significant reduction in infectivity was observed on day 7 (Mixed effects models, p < 0.0001). Spores pre-treated with helium resulted in the greatest reduction in infectivity, with a 60.68% decrease in spore load. By day 14, plasma- and PAW-treated groups exhibited a 79.60–95.96% reduction in spore load (mixed effects models, p < 0.0001). Similarly, bees fed ad libitum with sugar dissolved in PAW demonstrated an 83.54–95.19% reduction in spore load (Figure S1a). Additionally, bees fed ad libitum with sugar dissolved in He-PAW showed the lowest survival rates during days 3–5 of infection (ANOVA, p < 0.05) (Figure S1b). However, in this repeated trial, overall survival remained statistically similar across all treatments, ranging from 43.33 to 50.83% on day 14.
The in vivo effect of direct plasma and PAW on the number of N. ceranae spores in infected honeybees (a) and honeybee survival (b) over 14-day the experimental period. Thirty bees per treatment (n = 30) were collected on day 7 and different numbers of bees were collected for spore count on day 14: control Nosema (n = 23), liquid phase-Ar (n = 27), liquid phase-He (n = 33), PAW-Ar (n = 20), PAW-He (n = 19), sugar dissolved in PAW-Ar (n = 34) and sugar dissolved in PAW-He (n = 32). Lowercase letters indicate statistically significant differences (mixed effects models, p < 0.05). Honeybee survival differences between treatment groups were tested by ANOVA (p < 0.05) with comparisons made between treatment at each time interval.
Discussion
The control of Nosema disease is crucial for maintaining the health and productivity of honeybee colonies. Although, there are several strategies for Nosema control, each strategy comes with limitations. Residues in honey and hive products are a concern with fumagillin use, as well as resistance development to this chemical. Although, administering alternative treatments such as essential oils and plant extracts via sugar syrup is straightforward, variability in treatment outcomes is more closely related to the consistency, bioactivity of the extracts and the accuracy of dosage applied in bee hives. New technologies for controlling Nosema infections in honeybee colonies face significant challenges in practical application. Despite their promising potential, these methods often encounter barriers related to scalability and cost-effectiveness. Therefore, a suitable, safe and effective approaches to control Nosema disease is still needed. The current results clearly demonstrate the efficiency of non-thermal atmospheric pressure plasma on N. ceranae spore inactivation. Direct plasma and PAW were investigated for their capacities to inhibit N. ceranae both in vitro and in vivo. The direct plasma generated by argon and helium had a strong influence on N. ceranae spores, resulting in a maximal reduction of 96.55% and 96.05%, respectively, compared to a 12.38–77.14% spore reduction after 1 h of contact with PAW. The result corresponds with the leakage of UV-absorbing intracellular substances from the spores. An increase in UV–absorbing substance levels was observed when direct plasma was applied which is consistent with the findings from the Live/Dead assay. The inactivation of N. ceranae by argon and helium plasma may result from both physical and chemical effects. The chemical effect is attributed to RONS (OH, NO and O3), which are generated by argon and helium plasma. These reactive species generated in plasma are one possible mechanism responsible for the N. ceranae spores’ inactivation which can directly attack the cell wall of microbes, leading to rapid and extensive damage to cellular components such as membranes, proteins and DNA52,53. The dominant role of OH radicals for microbial inactivation have been previously reported. These radicals could interact with the cell wall and can readily oxidize biological molecules including phospholipid bilayer and proteins that comprise the bacterial cell wall54,55. Our results demonstrated that the intensity of main radical species (OH, NO and O3) had a correlation with the gas flow rate. Additionally, the physical processes produced by plasma such as shockwaves, UV light and electric fields can have an effect on N. ceranae spores54,56,57. In this study, the electric field could be responsible for inactivating N. ceranae spores, with input voltage of 6.89–11.92 kV applied over a distance of 3.0 cm for plasma production, the average electric field is 81.2 and 140 kV/m for argon and helium plasma, respectively. UV radiation may not play a key role in the inactivation of N. ceranae spores due to the low intensity of UV light detected (200–400 nm) (Fig. 1). The electric field leads to electropermeabilization and electroporation of cell membranes, which may be reversible58,59,60. These mechanisms can rupture the cell wall, allowing radical species to penetrate more effectively and exert oxidative damage to intracellular components, including nucleic acids and proteins61,62. Several studies have shown that electric fields can play an important role in the cell wall disruption of both gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria54,57,63 and yeast64. However, UV light has been reported to have a negligible effect on inactivation of bacteria54,65. The results of PAW showed that it was less effective, probably due to a lower concentration of charged species or the absence of some short-lived reactive species as was previously reported with bacteriophages and Aspergillus flavus49,53,66. Although RNS were not detected in the plasma-treated water, a slightly decrease in pH was observed following plasma treatment. This acidification is likely due to plasma-induced proton generation from water ionization and the formation of weak acids from reactive oxygen species67. Additionally, ambient CO₂ can dissolve into PAW, forming carbonic acid and contributing to the pH drop68,69. The results demonstrated that PAW generated by argon had a higher concentration of H2O2 after 10 min of exposure compared to PAW generated by helium. The production rate of H2O2 is influenced by the concentration of OH radicals. Although, our results showed that argon plasma generates lower OH radical intensity compared to helium plasma (Fig. 1), its higher electron density may enhance water molecule dissociation and promote sustained production of RONS70,71. However, the relationship between factors such as discharge power, electron density, plasma-liquid interface and H2O2 production should be further investigated. The higher concentration of H2O2 in argon-generated PAW may contribute to increased oxidative stress and compromised membrane integrity, leading to a more pronounced inactivation effect on N. ceranae spores. Since, nitrites and nitrates were not detected in PAW, we suggest that H2O2 could be considered as the key chemical for N. ceranae inactivation by PAW. Therefore, the effect of the mock solution was also evaluated. The results demonstrated that H2O2 concentrations greater than 50 mg/L caused a 42.64–49.75% reduction of spore count compared to a 12.38–77.14% reduction with PAW treatment. This suggests that other factors may contribute to the anti-N. ceranae activity. By contrast, Mentheour and Machala (2022) hypothesized that H2O2 could not be responsible for the penetration through the membrane of Escherichia coli60. The interaction of H2O2 with other species in PAW resulted in a stronger antibacterial activity60,72. Therefore, further studies are needed to specifically test the role of RONS, such as using antioxidants or additional assays to isolate their effects. Direct plasma and PAW inactivation of N. ceranae was further verified by the infectivity assay in adult honeybees. Our results indicated that both direct plasma and PAW could reduce the infectivity of N. ceranae spores in bees. The present study is the first to provide evidence for the use of direct plasma and PAW generated by argon and helium to provide anti-microsporidian activity. From the stated results, atmospheric pressure plasma holds significant promise for practical applications in the field, particularly for decontamination and sanitization of beekeeping equipment. One of the primary challenges in beekeeping is controlling honeybee pathogens that can adversely affect colony health. The use of atmospheric pressure plasma in the field would enable beekeepers to disinfect hive components, tools, frames and other equipment directly at the apiary, reducing the need for transporting equipment to specialized facilities. Furthermore, plasma treatment could reduce the pathogen load on equipment and prevent the spread of diseases between colonies, thereby improving the overall health of bee populations. Additionally, the application of PAW appears to be feasible for controlling pathogens such as N. ceranae in beehives. Our results demonstrated that H2O2, a key reactive oxygen species produced in PAW generated by argon and helium with the exposure time of 5 and 10 min, maintained approximately 50% of its initial concentration over a 14-day period (50–100 mg/L). These concentrations of mock H2O2 solutions resulted in a spore reduction of 16.24–42.64%. However, further investigation is needed to fully assess the effectiveness of PAW in inactivating Nosema in beehives. Given that atmospheric pressure plasma seems to be an attractive technology for controlling the honeybee diseases, further studies focused on the development of plasma devices and their safety for honeybees will have broad their applications in beekeeping.
Materials and methods
Plasma device and plasma-activated water (PAW) Preparation
The atmospheric-pressure plasma jet system was used in this study as detailed in Boonmee et al. (2024)48. The structure of plasma jet system is presented in Fig. 9. Argon and helium gases were separately injected into the device at different flow rate of 0.25 and 0.5 Lpm to generate plasma. The input voltage was 6.89 kV and 11.92 kV and the frequency was 1.66 MHz and 1.38 MHz for argon and helium, respectively (Fig. 10). The spectra of plasma jet emission were examined by Optical Emission Spectroscopy (AVANTES, USA). For PAW preparation, the 5 ml of sterile drinking water in the glass tube was treated under the jet nozzle. The working distance between a nozzle and water surface was 30 mm. Working gases with flow rate of 0.25 and 0.50 Lpm were applied with the exposure time of 3, 5 and 10 min.
N. ceranae spore propagation
Forager honeybees were collected from colonies in Phrae province, Thailand and processed for Nosema spp. identification using primer pairs of SSUrRNA-f1: CACCAGGTTGATTCTGCCT and SSUrRNA-r1b: TGTTCGTCCAGTCAGGGTCGTCA73 by Macrogen company (Macrogen, Singapore). Samples confirmed to be infected with N. ceranae were used to infect three-day-old, emerged worker bees for propagation. After 14 days, spores were harvested from the midguts of heavily infected honeybees and purified to obtain the large number of spores required for experiments26.
N. ceranae spore inactivation using the plasma jet
The purified spores containing 1 × 106 spores/ml were divided into 1 ml aliquots in glass tubes that were subsequently exposed to argon plasma and helium plasma. The plasma jet nozzle was placed at a distance of 30 mm from the surface of suspension (Fig. 9). Each working gas flow rate at 0.25 and 0.50 Lpm for 3 and 5 min were applied. Untreated-plasma spores were assigned as control. After plasma treatment, spore suspensions were incubated at 30 °C for 1 h. All treatments were run in triplicate for statistical analysis. Spores were then counted using a hemocytometer73,74.
Physicochemical properties and stability of hydrogen peroxide in PAW
The pH, conductivity and concentration of H2O2 were immediately measured after PAW generation. The pH and conductivity of PAW was measured by a pH meter (Mettler Toledo, Switzerland) and EC meter (Apera Instruments, USA), respectively. The concentration of the produced H2O2 was quantified using a colorimetric strip test (Supelco MQuant® 1.10337 and Supelco MQuant® 1.10081, Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany), while the nitrate and nitrite concentrations were measured using nitrate strip test (Supelco MQuant® 1.00020, Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany) following the manufacturer’s instructions. The test strip was immersed in the PAW for about three seconds. The color change was then observed and compared to a color chart on the strip bottle. To assess the stability of H2O2, PAW and 50% (w/v) sucrose solution dissolved in PAW were stored at room temperature for 14 days. The concentrations of H2O2 were quantified on day 0, 2, 6, 10, 12 and 14 of storage.
Anti-Nosema activity of PAW treatment
For the treatment of N. ceranae spores with PAW produced by argon and helium as working gas, 100 µl aliquots of spore suspensions (1 × 107 spores/ml) were added to the 1.5 ml centrifuge tube containing 900 µl of PAW. Spore suspensions in a 900 µl of sterile water was included as control. The samples were mixed and incubated at 30 °C for 1 h. Then, samples were analyzed for spore count using a hemocytometer74,75. Three replicates were performed in each treatment.
To determine the effects of H2O2 on N. ceranae inactivation, hydrogen peroxide (30%) (Merck, Germany) at known concentrations (0−300 mg/L) was prepared and used for N. ceranae spore treatments as described above.
LIVE/DEAD cell viability assay
The LIVE/DEAD™ BacLight™ Bacterial Viability (Invitrogen, Thermo Fisher Scientific, USA) was used to evaluate the viability of N. ceranae spores caused by plasma treatment according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Spore supernatants treated with plasma were centrifuged at 10,000 rpm for 10 min. The supernatants were discarded, and the pellets were resuspended in 500 µl of 0.85% (w/v) NaCl. A 1.5 µl of mixture of SYTO 9 and propidium iodide (PI) dyes was added to the spore suspensions and incubated at room temperature in the dark for 15 min. Then, 5 µl of stain solution was pipetted onto a slide glass and covered with coverslip. Fluorescence images were captured using an Olympus BX53-DP74 fluorescence microscope with a U-HGLGPS light source (Olympus, Japan). All images were analyzed using ImageJ software. Fluorescence intensities were measured at 530 nm for SYTO 9 (green, live cells) and 630 nm for PI (red, dead cells) using a Synergy HT Multi-Mode Microplate Reader (BioTek Instruments Inc.). The percentage of viable spores was calculated using the following formula: % Live = [Green fluorescence/(Green + Red fluorescence)] × 100.
Leakage of UV-absorbing substances
The UV-absorbing intracellular substances released from the cells was analyzed54,76,77,78,79. The untreated and treated spore suspensions were centrifuged at 12,000 rpm for 10 min to remove any cell debris. The release of UV-absorbing materials was measured based on the absorbance of 2 µl of supernatant at 260 and 280 nm with the Synergy HT Multi-Mode Microplate Reader using Gen 5TM 182 V1.09 data analysis software (BioTek Instruments Inc.).
Morphological analysis of N. ceranae spore
A scanning electron microscope (SEM) was used to investigate the structural changes in N. ceranae spores after plasma treatment (Carl Zeiss Auriga, Germany) (The Center for Scientific and Technological Equipment, Suranaree University of Technology, Nakhon Ratchasima, Thailand). The sample preparation and analysis were described by Boonmee et al. (2024)48.
Effect of plasma and PAW treatments on N. ceranae infection in honeybees
The individual infection of adult honeybees with N. ceranae spores was accomplished using cage experiments following the methods of Chaimanee et al. (2021)35. N. ceranae spores with a concentration of 1 × 106 spores/ml were individually treated with argon plasma and helium plasma (flow rate of 0.5 Lpm for 5 min) and concentration of 1 × 107 spores/ml were treated with PAW generated by each working gas (0.5 Lpm for 10 min). Spore suspensions were incubated at 30 °C for 1 h after gas plasma and PAW treatments. Seven treatments were created in this study; (1) bees fed with untreated spores (control), (2) bees fed with argon plasma-treated spores, (3) bees fed with helium plasma-treated spores, (4) bees fed with spores treated by PAW generated by argon, (5) bees fed with spores treated by PAW generated by helium, (6) bees inoculated with untreated spores and fed ad libitum with 50% sucrose solution dissolving with PAW generated using argon and (7) bees inoculated with untreated spores and fed ad libitum with 50% sucrose solution dissolving with PAW generated using helium. Three-day-old, emerged worker bees were individually fed with 2 µl of spores which each bee receiving approximately 2,000 spores. Forty bees were transferred to new plastic cup cages. In the treatment groups of 1−5, bees were fed ad libitum with 50% sucrose solution. The experiment was conducted as a two independent trials, each comprising three biological replicates per treatment group (first conducted in February 2023 and repeated in April 2025). Mortality was monitored and dead bees removed daily. Ten bees in each cage (30 bees/treatment) were collected on day 7 and all surviving bees were collected on day 14 of the infection for spore examination. The individual bee guts were homogenized in 1 ml of sterile water and the number of spores was counted under light microscope using a hemocytometer74,75.
Statistics
Statistical analysis was performed using JMP version 11.2 for Mac (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA). All data regarding the effects of the direct plasma and PAW on the number of N. ceranae spores, UV-absorbing intracellular substances, the physicochemical properties of PAW and H2O2 solutions on the spore count were checked for normality using the Shapiro–Wilk test. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Tukey-HSD analysis was performed when data were normally distributed. The data were compared using Kruskal–Wallis non-parametric test followed by a Steel–Dwass posthoc multiple comparisons test to separate means when significance was found. The effect of direct plasma and PAW treatments on N. ceranae infection in honeybees was analyzed by the mixed effects models. The survival of honeybees at each day of experiment was examined using the ANOVA. The statistical significance was set at p < 0.05.
Data availability
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.










댓글
댓글 쓰기